top headlinesfederal newsstate newslocal newsvoices


 

About this site


About the J-School

 

 

Buchanan, Reform Party Fall Short

By Bret Sigler

 

 

While George W. Bush and Al Gore wrangled over Electoral College votes in the closest election in recent history, third party candidate Patrick Buchanan was just hoping to capture at least five percent of the popular vote.

Final election results show that he will walk away with less than one percent.

Buchanan’s performance was crucial for the future of the Reform Party. If he secured five percent of the vote, the party would have received matching federal campaign funds for the 2004 presidential election. Instead, they’re back at square one.

Going into today’s race, the Buchanan camp wasn’t worried.

"We’re very confident that we’ll get five percent of the vote," said Brian Doherty, press director for the Buchanan campaign. "Polls are always underrepresented, especially for the conservative vote."

But still, many are left wondering if this election is the swan song for Buchanan and the Reform Party. Buchanan’s showing has been the worst since Texas billionaire Ross Perot founded the party in 1992. Perot won 20 percent of the vote in 1992 and nine percent in 1996.

"If they fail to get 5 percent, they’ll be way behind the eight ball," said Bruce Cain, director of the Institute for Governmental Studies at UC Berkeley, prior to tonights election. "Whether they are permanently behind the eight ball is hard to say."

Cain said the Reform Party’s dismal performance is largely due to its internal ideological split and the lack of a charismatic leader.

"They’re completely divided, and Perot doesn’t show any interest in reviving the party," he said.

The split became obvious in August, when a faction of the party broke away to support John Hagelin as the presidential candidate instead of Buchanan. Buchanan’s opponents were worried that he would commit the party social-conservative issues such as right to life and anti-gun control.

Cain also says that the Republicans and Democrats have stymied the Reform Party by hijacking the mainstays of its agenda.

"The Democrats stole the agenda on reducing the deficit and McCain stole the agenda on campaign reform," Cain said.

But Doherty says that this election is a step forward for the party despite the fact they didn’t get five percent of the vote.

"We’ll just have to go back to grassroots," he said. "If Buchanan’s issues don’t resonate in this election, they will resonate in the future."

But no matter what happens, Doherty said Buchanan has no plans to leave the party any time soon.

"He’s committed to the Reform Party," he said, adding that Buchanan may co-chair the party with Jerry Mann after the election.

Regardless, Cain said the future of third parties hinges on how well the next president will be able to avoid the perennial problems that frustrate voters, such as bipartisan bickering and congressional gridlock.

"The number of disgruntled voters is a factor of how well the system is performing."


 

UCB Journalism School